Clash Detection vs Clash Avoidance

Clive Jordan
4 min readJan 2, 2018

--

What if we could follow a PRIORITIZED Clash Avoidance workflow?

Once upon a time I held multiple drawings against a window to identify clashes.

Then along came new BIM technology that showed everyone else where I’d screwed up — more easily, more clearly and more quickly!

– thanks Navis 😆

Now times have changed again.

We now have the cloud for sharing live models.

It’s now easier than ever to get hooked into a ‘who gets there first wins’ mentality.

Unfortunately this new approach can result in thousands of costly-to-fix clashes.

In our eyes fixing of any clash is waste (virtually or not).

What if, we could use the technology advancements in our favor?

Could a prioritized clash avoidance workflow now be possible?

We believe that an element’s sequence should always be based on it’s priority.

image shows very generalized systems in an attempt to introduce concept
  • For example — gravity systems should hold a higher project priority than a single flexible conduit — right?
  • Another example — to re-route using multiple pipe welds requires more time and money compared to bending something flexible — right?
What would cost less to build?

If we can prioritize model elements maybe we could lock in the important stuff first?

But how do we do this?

We believe in a combination of collaborative BIM scoping and Lean.

The secret behind a 17% time saving on a 12 month design timeline — Design Pull Planning

Let’s prioritize elements before modeling so that we can avoid fixing more costly clashes later.

lodplanner.com together with tools like C4R and Clash MEP achieve a prioritized clash avoidance workflow.

That’s SmartLeanBIM™

www.lodplanner.com

Maybe you’d like to hear more as we progress on our journey to Smart.Lean.BIM.™ ?:

Owner: “I’ve been reading online about BIM” and “we’d like our project to be LOD 500 with COBie” Architect: we “usually do 200 and some 300” Owner: “if you can’t do this BIM thing I’ll have to get a… read more

A lot of the BIM revolution is about technology until we remind ourselves that it’s more about processes and people. Then we… read more

Here are 20 BIM features that are important to BIM experts from around the world: You want “embedded videos” in your BEPs — nice idea! You wanted read more

Our two weeks in London were exceptional — thanks to all of the amazing BIM champions that we had the opportunity to meet — in fact we… read more

Anyone remember when the guitarist Nigel Tufnel told a customer “these go to eleven”? Nigel was referring to the volume of his… read more

When I was ten years old I really wanted to buy a pool table. I’d been growing flowers in the back yard and selling them out the front of our house. However… read more

BIM Execution Plans are being created around the world to support BIM workflows and Global Building Information Modeling Standards are being developed and… read more

Over the past few years our small idea for better BIM planning has developed into a much larger and more global goal. This big passion to… read more

It’s been exciting for our small team to spend our days listening to your feedback and our nights reworking the product ready for the… read more

On Jan 1st I changed my title on LinkedIn but I didn’t anticipate the magnitude of what happened next. I’ve been completely stunned by the… read more

Originally published at www.lodplanner.com on January 2, 2018.

--

--

Clive Jordan
Clive Jordan

Written by Clive Jordan

Fighting “Evil BIM” @PlannerlyAEC

No responses yet